






Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Prepare for your exams
Study with the several resources on Docsity
Earn points to download
Earn points by helping other students or get them with a premium plan
Community
Ask the community for help and clear up your study doubts
Discover the best universities in your country according to Docsity users
Free resources
Download our free guides on studying techniques, anxiety management strategies, and thesis advice from Docsity tutors
A comprehensive analysis of the akashi-kaikyo bridge in japan, focusing on its design, construction, and engineering innovations. It delves into the bridge's unique features, including its wind-resistant design, seismic resilience, and the use of advanced damping systems. The document highlights the challenges faced during construction and the innovative solutions implemented to overcome them. It also explores the bridge's aesthetic design and its integration into the surrounding environment.
Typology: Study Guides, Projects, Research
1 / 10
This page cannot be seen from the preview
Don't miss anything!
Proceedings of Bridge Engineering 2 Conference 2007 27 April 2007, University of Bath, Bath, UK
Abstract: The aim of this conference paper is to analyse the Akashi Bridge. This analysis procedure will generally include considerations of aesthetics, loading, strength, serviceability, construction, temperature, creep, wind, durability, susceptibility to intentional damage, and possible future changes which the bridge might have to undergo. All aspects above will be critically examined in the context of how the design and/or construction of the bridge could have been improved. Keywords: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge, Suspension bridge, Laying down caisson method, Truss stiffening girder system, Tuned mass damper, Dry air injection system 1 General Introduction 1.1 Background of the bridge The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge, also known as pearl bridge, is a suspension bridge in Japan that crosses the Akashi Strait, it links Maiko in Kobe and Lwaya on Awaji Island as part of the Honshu-Shikoku Highway. 1.2 The reason to build Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge Before the Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge was built, ferries carried passengers across the Akashi Strait in Japan. This dangerous waterway often experiences severe storms, and in 1955, two ferries sank in the strait during storm, killing 168 children. The ensuring shock and public outrage convinced the Japanese government to draw up plans for a suspension bridge to cross the strait. The original plan was for a mixed railway-road bridge but when the bridge was begun in April 1986, it was restricted to road only, with six lanes. Actual construction did not begin until May 1988, and the bridge was opened for traffic on April 5,
gravel layer in the late Pliocene and the early Pleistocene) and the Alluvium layer are deposited.
The deck could accommodate 6 lanes for motorway traffic and the design speed for vehicles is 100km/h, no lanes for light traffic. And the maintenance traffic used the wide steel grid platform at the lower level of stiffening girder trusses. And the deck was designed to be flexible that had an allowance of 8m upwards displacement, 5m downwards displacement and 27m horizontal displacement in each direction. Ref [9] 3 Loading In the process of analysis of the bridge, I have made assumption that the worst case is the span in the middle, which has a span length of 15m between two cable hangers. And it is simply supported by two cables. 3.1 The ultimate limit state The overall dead load of the bridge is 140 KN/m The superimposed load of the bridge is 20 KN/m The Traffic Live Load: The carriageway of the bridge is 35.5m which is equal to 6 notional lanes. And the corresponding nominal HA udl is 30KN/m, KEL per notional lane is 120KN and HB KN per axis loading is equal to 250 KN for a 9.8m long truck. For the wind load, I first calculate the maximum wind gust Vc by
Where V is the mean hourly wind speed, K 1 is a wind coefficient, S 1 is a funneling factor generally taken as 1. and S 2 is the gust factor. Table 1: Maximum wind gust Vc V K 1 S 1 S 2 Vc 37 m/s 1.5 1.0 1.36 75.48 m/s The horizontal wind load can be calculated by equation
Where q=0.613 Vc ² , A 1 is the solid horizontal projected area in m² and CD is the drag coefficient. Table 2: Horizontal wind load Pt q A 1 CD Pt 3492 N/m² 13937 m² 1.3^ 31.78^ KN/m And the uplift force by wind are calculated by equation
Where q is the dynamic pressure head A 3 is the plan area and CL is lift coefficient. Table 3: Uplift wind load Pv After finding the value ofγf l andγf 3 , we can then find the factored loadings. Table 4: Factored Loadings γf l γf 3 Loading^ Factored Loading Dead Load 1.05 1.10 140 KN/m 161. KN/m Superimposed Dead Load 1.75 1.10 20 KN/m 38.5 KN/m Traffic Live Load HA 1.10 1.10 70 KN/m 84.7 KN/m Traffic Live Load HB
Traffic Live Load KEL
Wind Load Uplift Suction 1.10 1.10 49.59 KN/m 60.0 KN/m Wind Load Horizontal 1.10 1.10 31.78 KN/m 38. KN/m Because of the uplift wind load would cancel out the other downward loadings, so the worst case should be the first combination of load, which is all permanent loads plus primary live loads. And I work out the maximum bending moment at the mid span is equal to 11060. KNm. By using the following equation, I can work out the depth of the deck which can take the calculated moment above.
σ I y M 275 N/mm² 23.67 m4 3.5m 1859785.71 KNm Where M is the bending moment, σ is the design strength of material, I the second moment of area and y is the distance between point and nature axis. In conclusion the calculated M is far too much bigger than the one the bridge need. There may be some thing wrong in my assumption, such as the estimated value of I for the girder section and the position of the natural axis. And then I work out the stress induced by the change of temperature by using the following equation
∆T α E σ 20 ℃ 12x 106 /℃ 200000 48 N/mm² Where σ is the stress induced, ∆T is the change of temperature, α is the coefficient of thermal expansion and E is the Young Modulus of steel. The axial stress induced by change of temperature is 48n/mm². And in fact, the design of the bridge tower is flexible to take than thermal expansion and it allow an expansion of 1.45m with the present of the expansion joint. So this should not be a problem in term of this. q A 3 CL Pv 3492 N/m² 70680.5 m² 0.4 49.49 KN/m
4 Aesthetics Because the bridge was to be located within easy access of many people, aesthetic design with the following themes was developed. Figure 6: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge 4.1 Function The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge expresses its structure in a pure and clear form. Every element of the bridge were showed clearly such as the supporting tower, the deck, the stiffening truss, etc. From its appearance, you can easily identify the function of each part of the bridge. Although it had the world longest suspending span, the truss structure would still give people a feeling of stability. It has an impression that the bridge can withstand every kind of load caused by typhoon, earthquake or heavy traffic And suspension bridge was the best suitable bridge type for this wide strait by having only two main supporting tower without disturb the marine traffic. 4.2 Proportions The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge had an excellent proportion between the height, length and spans. The proportion between them was just right for a bridge. Figure 7: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge showing its proportion 4.3 Order The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge had a very good order. The amount of lines and edges were just enough. And all straight line appeared on the bridge are very clear, showing a very good order in the bridge. 4.4 Refinement The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge shows a very good combination between light and shadow that it expresses essence of beauty of the Seto-Inland Sea, harmony and relentless change of the light and the shadow. Figure 8: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge showing its order 4.5 Integration into the environment The Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge looks absolutely beautiful across a wide span of water as a suspension bridge Its simple combination of tower and cable gives people a feeling of claim, as claim as the gentle sea water. 4.6 Surface texture In the design of Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge, the engineers use several different types of concrete to construct the anchorages, foundation and the deck. Therefore there will be different appearance for different parts of the bridge. Figure 9: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge 4.7 Colour The designer chose the colour of green-gray for the bridge. It was because the colour matched the design themes and evoked forest-rich Japan. In addition, the bridge illumination was arranged, in which the colour of cable illumination can be changed monthly or seasonally following pre-determined plan.
5.2.1Considerations After considering the size of the foundations and relatively soft supporting ground, they developed a new seismic design method and apply it on the bridge design, in which concepts of ‘the effective seismic motion’ and ‘dynamic damping effect by interaction between foundation and ground’ were introduced. Also the engineers calculated the two most critical types of earthquakes as factors in designing the bridge. The first one was an earthquake of magnitude 8.5 on the Richter scale with an epicenter distance of 150Km, and the other one was occurring with a recurrent cycle of 150 years within a 300Km of radius of the bridge site. Results from these tests were then applied into the design standards of the bridge. Ref [11] Figure 13: Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge model under seismic vibration 5.2.2 Tuned Mass Damper Under these considerations, they installed a tuned mass damper, which was tuned to specifically counter harmful frequencies of oscillation, to resist the vibration by both strong wind and earthquake. These vibrations would cause the main support towers to sway and would lead to failure. So inside the system, there is a 10 ton pendulum damper which would swing in the opposite direction of the main support towers movements to keep them stable. Ref [12] Figure 14: Location of Tuned Mass Damper 5.2.3 Temporary Active Mass Damper for erection of min tower They also use the temporary active tuned mass damper in the erection of main towers of the bridge. The application to free standing main tower of about 300m high Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge was really effective in reducing a variety of wind-induced vibrations which were estimated in the wind tunnel studies in advance. These devices also worked as a sort of an exciter to carry out the field observations later. As for the main tower of this bridge, the system gave passive type of damping systems were to be installed inside the tower sections and between the stiffening girder and the towers. Figure 15: Installation of vibration control devices in the Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge, (a) free standing tower of 300m high, (b) a set of active damper system applied to erection stage only. The damping system was first accidentally tested by Kobe earthquake on January 17, 19995 during its construction. And fortunately these seismic designs were succeed to withstand the seismic vibration earthquake in 1995 without receiving any structural damage. Ref [13] 6 Temperature Most parts of the Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge were made of steel. And steel would undergo thermal expansion and contraction. This caused both the deck and the tower had a significant expansion in their length. And this would result in introducing a large amount of moments and shear forces on the piers. And the design of the pier was to be flexible facing this problem. The pier would allow the movement to occur in order to reduce the induced moment and share forces to the least. Moreover, these expansions would cause the tower to incline. So the inspectors would carry out the measurement of the degree of inclination of the tower only at night when the temperature is relatively stable. Measurement was performed by geometer attached the block mirror in tower. And the result was understood that high accuracy of 29mm was attainted as an inclination of the main tower. And with the presence of the expansion joint, the stiffening girder had a horizontally allowance of 1.45m. Ref [14]
7 Improvement 7.1 For Substructures 7.1.1 Prolonging the life of concrete structures The environmental conditions for the concrete structures of Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge were so severe that they have to maintain with the utmost care and cost. Moreover, it is very difficult to approach the parts of them because of the height to pass marine traffic. Therefore, they could conduct high investigation of accuracy instead of usual maintenance and select the suitable maintain method for these concrete structures. Also the could employ pre-cast concrete panels or paint coating on surface concrete in order to prolong the life and to keep the beauty. Ref [15] 7.1.2 Maintenance for underwater steel structures The engineers used the Laying-Down Caisson Method to construct the underwater foundations of the bridge. By inspection, they found that there were hole corrosion on the body of caissons. To solve this problem, they could use Electro Deposit Method, which is one of the countermeasures for corrosion of underwater structures and covers surface of structure with the deposit bonded by slight electric current, in order to protect the steel from hole corrosions. [16] 7.2 For Cable 7.2.1 Dry Air Injection System for main cables The conventional anti-corrosion method for the main cable is such a system composed of zine galvanization of steel wires, and obstruction of seepage of rain water into the cables with paste applied to the cables and with wrapping as well as painting. However, survey on the bridge revealed that prevention of seepage of water was insufficient. In order to solve this problem, they installed the dry air injection system to keep the interior surface of the main cable out of water. Ref [17] (a) (b) 7.2.2 The non-destructive inspection for suspender rope A newly developed non0estructive inspection technique that used an electromagnetic method to identify the degree of internal corrosion of the suspender ropes by comparing the amount of flux between the intact cross section and corroded cross section. This could help to reduce the life cycle cost of the ropes because they could realize the appropriate repair time and select the adequate repair method by the calculation based on the data acquired by this method. Ref [18] Figure 17: Principle of Main Flux Method 7.2.3 Damping of wind inducted oscillation The suspender cable of Akashi-Kaikyo Bridge is Parallel-Wires Strand wire covered by Poly-Ethylene tube and two suspender cables at one point. Originally, a connecting type damper with high damping rubber was installed amid pair of the hangers in order to suppress vortex-induced vibration, which had limited amplitude and was generated at relatively low wind speed, but the damper was eventually destroyed from large amplitude oscillation by high wind speed. The reason of this phenomenon is considered to be wake induced flutter, which had not been anticipated to occur at this center spacing. Wind tunnel test was conducted to investigate the reason, occurring conditions and mechanism of such oscillation. After that, the engineers used a twisting thin wires surround the cables to reduce the oscillation in order to improve the aerodynamic characteristic of cable. Ref [19] 7.4 For Super structure 7.4.12 Magnetic wheel gondola Conventionally, gondolas were used for the repainting of the main tower of bridge, however, the gondolas would shake in the wind, thus the efficiency of the work decreases and it becomes danger. They could use magnetic wheel gondola with strong magnets in order to stick in on the tower wall. Also there were an object for tower wall and an object for diagonal and horizontal member in the gondola, so it could approach all over the tower member. This would improve the efficiency and degree of safety. Ref [20] Figure 16: Dry Air Injection System for the main cable
[9]. Information about truss stiffening girder by http://homepage1.nifty.com/momotaroh/E_sub07_1. html and Roads & Bridges magazine http://www.roadsbridges.com/Akashi-Kaikyo- Bridge-article [10]. Wind tunnel test result and analysis methods in Historical view of long-span bridge aerodynamics by Toshio Miyata of Department of Civil Engineering, Yokohama National University, Yokohama 240-8501, Japan [11]. Earthquake calculation by http://homepage1.nifty.com/momotaroh/E_sub07_1. html and Roads & Bridges magazine http://www.roadsbridges.com/Akashi-Kaikyo- Bridge-article [21]. Information about improvement for superstructure by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [22]. Information about improvement for superstructure by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [12]. Information about tuned mass damper by Roads & Bridges magazine http://www.roadsbridges.com/Akashi-Kaikyo- Bridge-article [13]. Information about temporary active damper by Roads & Bridges magazine http://www.roadsbridges.com/Akashi-Kaikyo- Bridge-article [14]. Information about thermal expansion of different parts of the bridge by http://homepage1.nifty.com/momotaroh/E_sub07_1. html [15]. Information about improvement for substructure by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [16]. Information about improvement for substructure by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [17]. Information about improvement for cable by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [18]. Information about improvement for cable by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [19]. Information about improvement for cable by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html [20]. Information about improvement for superstructure by Honshu- Shikoku Bridge Expressway Company Limited http://www.jb- honshi.co.jp/english/index.html